My husband and I are going to the North Fork for our anniversary the last weekend in Oct. We're should arrive from the city around 7 on Friday evening. I was thinking we would walk around the town and maybe stop in someplace to grab food (making a reservation at Frisky Oyster for Sat night) but is not making a reservation a bad idea? We would do something super casual - maybe sit at a bar and have a few drinks at a pub type or cozy little place. Please let me know if I'm setting us up for disapointment and any places that might fit the bill. Thanks!