Several months ago, I sought some advice on where my wife and I should dine in Rome. We appreciated all the helpful replies and now that we’re back from our trip abroad, here’s our report from Rome, which serves as our thanks.
Tuesday night, October 5, tired, hungry, and without a reservation, we walked to Ristorante Grano where we wanted to have a casual dinner outside. We arrived around 9:00PM and we were immediately seated at a table among other English-speaking diners. Our waiter was pleasant, but seemed to disappear for long stretches, especially after we asked for the check at the end of the meal. From the English menus, we ordered and split spaghetti carbonara and rigatoni all’amatriciana to start. Neither was particularly outstanding. The carbonara was drenched in a heavy sauce and I couldn’t find the pecorino or guanciale flavors anywhere. To be fair, my wife, who has a better palette than me, thought the flavor was as it should be. The amatriciana was good, but the sauce tasted more like marinara—it wasn’t spicy and there was very little pancetta. Our entrees were just disappointing. I ordered veal saltimbocca alla romana and my wife ordered calamari. I’ve made better saltimbocca at home. The sauce was flat and the bright flavors usually associated with the dish were conspicuously absent. Worse, the veal was tough. The breaded calamari was soggy, under-seasoned, and very chewy. It may have been the worst dish we’ve experienced in Italy. We passed on dessert and paid our €87 bill, which included a bottle of white table wine. We didn’t have high expectations prior to dinner, and Grano didn’t exceed them.
The next night we dined at Osteria La Gensola in Trastevere. I reserved a table at 7:30PM over the Internet two month in advance—probably more lead time than required, but I wanted to guarantee the table and move on to planning other aspects of our trip. We arrived on time to find an empty restaurant and we were given a choice table and menus written in Italian. Both of us speak enough Italian to express ourselves, but neither of us knew enough to understand every menu item, as some items were specific varieties of vegetables or cuts of fish or meat, some of which were locally obtained. Our waiter graciously and patiently answered all our questions—in Italian when we understood it and in English when we couldn’t. As time passed, the tables around us filled with diners speaking Italian, and the spirited din reached a crescendo around 9:00PM. We ordered a bottle of 2006 Cusumano Nero d’Avola (recommended by our waiter) and we were brought a treat from the kitchen: baby anchovies with tomatoes in a chickpea puree—a nice, unexpected way to start our meal. After, we shared an outstanding appetizer of tuna meatballs in a delicious tomato sauce. The meatballs melted like M&Ms. Next, my wife had rigatoni all’matriciana and I had calamari and spaghetti tossed with olive oil, sun-dried tomatoes, parsley, and fennel seed. The matriciana was good, but could have benefited from a few more hot pepper flakes, but the calamari and spaghetti was everything that I want in pasta when in Italy: simple and fresh. My wife, not normally a fan of fennel seed, thought the ingredient made the dish. For the entrees, we ordered coda alla vaccinara and monkfish cheeks in tomato sauce. Both were fantastic. The meat from the oxtail offered no resistance when pulled from the bone and the sauce was deliciously rich. The fish cheeks were perfectly cooked and the dish was light and fresh, similar to a puttanesca sauce. We don’t normally order desert, but since everything else was so good we thought it might be best to try a slice of chocolate cake and cassata siciliana. The chocolate cake was good, but the cassata siciliana was excellent; it’s filling reminded me of the filling found in a good cannoli. The bill was €138. Obviously, we loved La Gensola. Our waiter was friendly and helpful and the food was superlative. La Gensola’s atmosphere was what I would think most people seek; a neighborhoody kind of place where the chef inspects a delivery of live crustaceans in the dining room and where English pleasantly absent.
Thursday night, we were excited to dine at Al Ceppo since the chef of an Italian restaurant of which we’re fond recommended it. Like La Gensola, I made a reservation over the Internet two months in advance for a table at 8:00PM. There were a handful of guests already in the middle of their meals when we arrived. We were promptly shown to our table in a very brightly lighted, proper space where figures in large oil paintings watched over the room. Once we settled into our seats, we noticed that many of the diners were speaking English. Again, we found the Italian menu (which was seasonal specific) above our Italian reading level. Our waiter was happy to translate it. To start, we split an octopus, shaved celery stalk, and celery leaf salad. The octopus was overcooked and very chewy—disappointing. We each ordered pasta: I had spaghetti tossed with tuna, tomato, capers, breadcrumbs, and hot pepper flakes; sort of a refined take on spaghetti puttanesca. We both thought it was very well done. My wife had ziti tossed with lamb and ricotta meatballs, artichokes, and olive oil topped with flakes of parmigiano cheese. It sounded fantastic, but the dish was pretty bland. Eating the dish was a bit of a chore. [A quick aside…has the serving size of pasta increased in Rome recently? Both pasta dishes at Al Ceppo were huge. And the dishes at La Gensola were very generous too. This surprised us.] After the pasta, we had grilled lamb chops served with artichokes and potato wedges as well as grilled fish (kingfish, perhaps?) with grilled tomato, zucchini, and eggplant. The lamb was outstanding and perfectly cooked. Unfortunately, the fish was overcooked like the octopus, a bit dry, and forgettable. Ordering fish may have been a mistake. Perhaps we should have taken a cue from the large grill at the front of the house on which all sorts of delicious looking meats were grilling? We thought grilled fish would be within Al Ceppo’s area of expertise, but maybe not. Along with dinner we drank a good bottle of wine that was recommended by our waiter, but neither of us can remember any details aside from its color (red). We passed on desert and paid the €141 bill. We had high expectations before dinner and we left a little disappointed. Half our meal was very good, which only accentuated the deficiencies of the other half. Given that Al Ceppo was so highly praised, by our source and by other members of Chowhound, it’s possible that we simply ordered the wrong items. Perhaps it deserves a second look…
Updated 1 year ago | 0
Updated 1 year ago | 12
Updated 2 days ago | 1
Updated 1 year ago | 7
Updated 8 days ago | 86