Okay, three strikes against me, I don't remember the name of the place, the location of the place and it has been 15 years since I was last there but I have a friend going to NYC for the first time and they wanted to go to a 'Classic old style Italian' place near the Theater District and if I can find the name of this place and where it is it would fit the bill perfectly.
Some hints to what it was:
The place was very celebrity friendly (last time I was there Bob Fosse was eating at the table next to me, John Candy and Roger Ebert were across from me and several other Broadway celebs were in the crowd) but not a lot of gawkers.
They place had been there for YEARS!!!!!! Although the last time I was there was the early 90's (living in Denver I don't get back to The City much).
It was a very popular spot AFTER the shows.
I think it was named after two guys (of course Italian names) like Tony and Sals or something like that.
It was famous or a dessert of a plate of strawberries the size or your fist with whipped cream on top when the strawberries were available.
The portions were very generous, the food classic Italian and the place was always packed.
Sorry, I don't have any more to go on. If I hit the streets of NYC I could probably find it.