So, the place I drove past on an empanada hunt a few weeks ago turned out to be golden. For lunch today I made my way back to Rinconcito Migueleño on Westchester Ave. in Port Chester. Migueleño is a Salvadoran-Guatemalan restaurant though the menu feels more of the former than the latter.
As tacos are the quality benchmark for any Mexican taqueria, pupusas are my benchmark for any Salvadoran restaurant. So I ordered two pupusas - queso con loroco and chicharrón. I threw in a chorizo taco to check out the Guatemalan side of the menu.
The pupusas were fantastic. They had a mildly crisp exterior, not tough, heavy, chewy or greasy - the usual culprits in a sub-par pupusa. The interior was soft with a strong masa flavor. The queso con loroco pupusa is comfort food at its best: a half-inch thick masa tortilla filled with hot stringy cheese punctuated with the herby loroco. The chicharrón pupusa was equally satisfying.
The vinegary slaw and tomato sauce/salsa that accompanied the pupusas were perfect too, providing the requisite sharp flavor to cut the richness of the pupusas. All in all, these were the best pupusas I’ve had anywhere around these parts - and every bit on par with the great ones I had from some of the pupuserias in San Francisco’s Mission District a few weeks ago.
Needless to say, this beats its Port Chester Salvadoran neighbors - Rinconcito Salvadoreño, El Tesoro II and Pupusa Loco - hands down.
The taco, on the other hand, was a disappointment. My favorite part about Guatemalan tacos is that they are usually made with thick, hand made tortillas. But Migueleño’s were made with standard Mexican tortillas. And while the chorizo filling is distinctly different from a Mexican chorizo, it’s just not worth going there when the pupusas are so good and you can get truly outstanding tacos only a few doors up the road.
All told, the pupusas will set you back $1.50 each, and the tacos another $2.50 each. The best bet is to get the $6.50 special, which comes with 2 pupusas, beans and plantains. That's my kind of price...
118 Westchester Avenue, Port Chester, NY