Hey All, first time poster, long time reader. Can anyone recommend a a restaurant for a pre-broadway dinner for two. I would prefer somewhere quiet with bonus points for an Itailian spot. We are celebrating a year together and I want this to be special but am on a tight budget. $150 dollars including drinks (probably 2-3 glasses of wine) but I would be willing to push up to 200 if the place really blew me away. No seafood! :-)
Any information that anyone could provide me would be wonderful as I am a complete newbie to NYC.