Every Friday, our office orders a bunch of pizzas for lunch (10-12 large pies). For the last 2 years I've been working here, it's been utterly terrible.
Our current supplier is Mozzarelli's, which is only somewhat terrible. They seem to do a few things well, but others very poorly. They're also inconsistent; our first order was great, the owner/chef/pizzaguy delivered some samples himself, and they were quite good. Once they had us hooked in, and giving them a $300 order each week, the quality dropped off.
Prior to Mozzarelli's, we ordered from Bravo, which was usually truly horrible. Only the plain cheese was mildly acceptable, probably due to the lack of crap ingredients.
People here are ready for a change, so I'm looking for recommendations for some decent New York style pizza that will deliver to around 19th St. and 5th Ave. It doesn't have to be fancy, just good, consistent New York pizza.