I live near Ottomanelli Brothers and have read about the one in the West Village.
A quick trip over to citysearch reveals that there are in fact multiple throughout the city with different names, does anyone know if it is all the same family or what? (They have separate websites, too!) What's the best meat at each? Any of you use Ottomanelli as your neighborhood butcher?
1. Ottomanelli Brothers
395 Amsterdam Ave at 79th St
2. O. Ottomanelli's & Sons Prime Meat Market
285 Bleecker St at 7th Av So
3. Ottomanelli Meat Market
1549 York Ave at 82nd St
Okay maybe I'm just a bit too curious about obscure NYC history...