We have a couple of friends coming to Nantucket for the first time. We have reservation at the Summer House and I've heard that the food is not what it has been in the past so we are thinking of going to the Straight Wharf. We have not been to either place in a couple of years, but we have enjoyed both of the them in the past and we are curious if anyone has had any recent experience with either. We would also welcome any other recommendations (we are heading to the Galley tonight).
Also a bit of background on our friends; they are from the midwest, and are meat and potato fans. While we would love to try American Season's or Company of the Cauldron, I think our friends would like something more traditional.