i did some searching and it seems like Bhojan is popular (was also well reviewed for its sweets by the Voice last year)
Do any of the other places make their own? I know we got some pretty good barfi from kalustyans for diwali, and while i thought they said they were made there, i think it was a special occasion thing and not available at other times of year.
Would be willing to make multiple stops too if only a specific type of sweet can be recommended (looking for barfi, rasmalai, gulab jamun).
102 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016