I'm getting desperate! My two favorite places have gone downhill. Where is the good take-out pizza in the Middletown-Hazlet-Holmdel area? I prefer a thinner crust, but I'd be happy with any type, as long as it's tasty and good quality.
I have tried the following:
- Naples in Belford. Decent.
- Valentino's in Belford. Good, not great.
- Villa in Holmdel (Kohl's Plaza) Good, not great.
- Pasquales in Middletown, across from Starbucks. I don't like their pies. Some of the special slices are ok.
My old favorites were Hazlet Pizza, and the rectangular pie at Luigis on Middle Rd. I no longer recommend them. They are lackluster.