Since your post is locked I'll give my suggestion here. Rouget is good, been several times. But not all that close to Titusville (my home town).
Right nearby in Pennington, just off Rt 31 is a BYOB named ZA. I first went there July 2, 2006 just a few days aafter they opened and I have been going back regularly ever since. Too bad it is November, they have a lovely patio covered with Wysterai during summer.