I have been looking for authentic Jamaican beef patties in the city for months. All of the resturants seem to get their supply from the same bakery on the Northside, which sucks. Looking in resturants are useless.
The best patties can be bought frozen from the Hyde Park Co-op. They sell Tower Isle Beef Patties, in cocktail and full size, mild and spicy. They are in the freeze case in the Pizza Aisle. Tower Isle is a Brooklyn company that packages their beef patties.
3 full size for $4.69
12 Cocktail size for $5.09