I'm taking my fiancee for a Saturday night out to the theater, and would like to treat her to a really nice meal afterwards. Our show starts at 8:00pm and runs two and a half hours, so realistically we need a 11pm reservation. I've looked at many of the well known upscale restaurants and most seem to close at 11.
For reference, I really liked the look of Gotham Bar & Grill -- menu, atmosphere, and price point.
It doesn't have to be near the theaters, cab ride is fine as long we stay in Manhattan. What are my options?