I was trying to decide between Grotto and Bistro 5 for next Sat. night. I searched the board and found the exact same question from Aug. 05. I have been to both and am leaning toward Grotto. However, I love the neighborhood feel of Bistro 5 even though I prefer the Grotto menu. Does anyone have an recent experiences to comment about? We are getting a babysitter for the night, and want to make it worthwile. Another option is Catch in Winchester. I have never been, but have heard good things. Thanks in advance. I appreciate all advice.