I can never reply to a post so I have to write a separate post.
I don't recommend the Water Club very highly. It is overpriced, overrated,
service is sometimes rude. One chowhound looking to throw a private party got
attitude when calling to inquire about party prices and availablity.
I haven't gone in a year or two and it was just okay. From what I understand
my opinion is quite common. It isn't what it used to be. If you are looking for
a romantic setting, water view, impeccable service and looking to impress,
try the River Cafe, Water Street across the Brooklyn Bridge. The view is unsurpassed,
better to look at the NY Skyline and the Statue of Liberty than Queens and the food and
service are right up there with the view! I was there last Saturday night for my birthday.
Please refer to my post about River Cafe in one of the sections, cravings or general or
here. As a matter of fact, I cannot decide which was better. I was with 6 people and
we couldn't decide whose food was better.
I hope I helped...Enjoy