Ok, I have made my preference for Chicago style pizza by Rosati's in Oconomowoc (sp?) known. There are two Rosati's pizza chains in the area. This is the good one. Despite my best efforts, my teenager likes Pizza Hut. Now, having worked with a NY team when I was living in exile in Charleston, SC, the best pizza everyone agreed with in the south was (I kid you not) Mario's or Luigi's outside of our Marine Corps customer in NC. To keep good quality, Mario ran Luigi's and vice versa. My NYC employees would fedex pizzas in from them for special meals.
Leonadaro's in Mequon is OK and the best alternative for me, but as I am trying to educate the kid from his fast food mother, anyone who tries to do a Brooklyn pizza in the area would be appreciated. Where you have to hold the slice and grease runs down your arm, etc.