Chowhound Presents: |


Dutch Ovens

Choosing between 2 gifts: Dutch ovens?


More from Cookware

Cookware Dutch Ovens

Choosing between 2 gifts: Dutch ovens?

Chaotik_lord | | Jan 19, 2013 09:39 PM

Over Christmas, I received two very different items in response to my request for a Dutch oven. One is a Calphalon 7 qt. Kitchen Essentials Anodized aluminum Dutch oven. It is oven safe to 400 degrees with lid.

The other is a Michele B. Cast Iron Lite 5 qt soup pot (an enameled cast iron). It is oven safe to 500 degrees without the lid, but only to 350 degrees with the lid. Additionally, the lid has a steam hole, which seems to counter the purpose of a Dutch oven.

Both lids are glass.

A couple of other things to consider are that I have a soup/stock pot already that I adore, so I don't need the soup aspect so much. I want a Dutch oven for the sealed cooking, and for the stove-to-oven capabilities in particular. Finally, I plan to exchange whichever one I don't keep for a nice cast iron skillet, fryer, or chef's pan.

With all of that in mind...which one should I keep and why? I'm leaning towards the Calphalon if only because of the lid, but will the 400 degree limit be problematic?