Scibelli's Pizza at the Ronkonkoma Station (near Long Island Islip / MacArthur Airport) is reason enough to fly in there instead of La Guardia...
Well, maybe that's an exaggeration... but if you're flying in anyway, don't miss this awesome pie. The plain slice is GREAT, the pesto great, the Sicilian great... the Italian Sausage is weak... but overall this place is two thumbs up plus. FWIW I'm an obsessive "pizza taster and rater" and this is about as good as I've found in any boro, period.
BTW, they are exapanding to include a sit-down place, right now it's just two tables, mostly takeout by pie or slice.
Updated 4 days ago | 3
Updated 3 months ago | 14
Updated 1 year ago | 1
Updated 1 year ago | 2
Updated 2 years ago | 7