I'm looking for a place for an anniversary dinner in January. I've recently moved to the city from New York, and would love to find a place that had really great food with a romantic atmosphere, but without the flourishes of "fine dining." In New York we had great anniversary dinners at Mas Farmhouse and Blue Hill, and would love to know if there's anything comparable.
I've read about Vetri's restaurants, but Vetri and Osteria are booked for the night I'm looking. Also, it looks like Fountain is closed that night (though I think it'd be the wrong atmosphere anyway). I also assumed LBF would be too stuffy too, but if not, please let me know.
As far as cuisine goes, I think anything except for Asian and Indian. Would love to know your thoughts!
Tentatively, I have reservations at Il Pittore and Fish, but think I could do better. Any help would be much appreciated.
**Edit: So I've also looked into Meme and Farm and Fisherman. Anyone care to weigh in on those options?