A friend and I will see a play during the week and want to get a quick bite afterwards. Time will be around 9:30-ish. The place should have good service and with a noise level low enough to allow for easy conversation; ability to make reservations would be a plus. The closer to 50th & Broadway the better. Price not an issue. Doesn't have to be fancy, but also shouldn't be a dive. (My friend is in his 60s and retired after a successful career.) Maybe Insieme would fit the bill? I've only been once but wasn't so focused on service.
Thanks in advance for ideas.