So my husband and I are spending Christmas with my family visiting NYC. We're also going to be celebrating our 1st anniversary, and we were hoping to celebrate by going out to dinner the night of December 26th, a Saturday. Maybe this is too specific but we're looking for something
* tasty (of course)
* not overly expensive (maybe $25 plates at the most)
* close to our hotel on Times Square (we'd like to walk there and back)
* romantic (again, of course)
* not overly touristy (which might be hard to do by Times Square?)
I've been looking through the boards for awhile, but I haven't seen anything that seemed quite right...or if I saw it I'm not familiar enough with NYC geography to know.