The Worst (And Best) Kitchen Counter Options

As Gale Sitomer of Gale Sitomer Design says, "Stained countertops give the impression of poor maintenance and can make the kitchen feel dated or unclean."

You can call in a professional to tackle any sanding and polishing — but if it's a lost cause, a low-cost, neutral countertop replacement might be worth it in the long-run.

"[Butcher block counters] are prone to damage and stains, and they wear over time, making them less appealing to buyers," says Sitomer.

Expensive stone and other bespoke options like rare marble, quartzite, and ultra-thick waterfall countertops are bad investments unless you sell in a luxury market.

Natural stone must be properly maintained, and buyers may see it as a lot of upkeep. If your heart set is on it, consider something neutral and durable, like granite.

Tile countertops can be beautiful but may have a stigma similar to a butcher's block. Light-colored grout will quickly show its age and often looks dirty.

Laminate countertops are notorious for grout stains and will make your home feel instantly outdated. It's best to replace or at least resurface them.