This flavor combined milk and white chocolate ice cream with miniature milk and white fudge cows. This "swirled" pint was an unusual pairing loved by fans.

With a sweet custard ice cream and caramelized sugar swirl, this is one of the brand's less fancy offerings, but one reviewer criticized its sweet-on-sweet flavor.

Ben & Jerry's itself rated its Peanut Butter and Jelly flavor as one of its 10 weirdest flavors. Perhaps it is a flavor best left to the sandwich realm.

Inspired by a "Saturday Night Live” sketch, this vanilla ice cream has a hint of rum and fudge-covered rum and malt balls, proving that the brand has a sense of humor.

This mix of coffee ice cream and Kahlua liqueur was a dream flavor for any ice cream fiends who love a good boozy drink, but it won't return from the Flavor Graveyard.