Primal Kitchen

This sauce is the only one listed that caters to paleo, keto, and Whole30 lifestyles. It's made with avocado oil and other ingredients with familiar names.

It is pricey, though, at $8 for 7.5 ounces on their website. Taste-wise, it has been compared to ranch, and some reviewers call it a little too watery.

Frisch's Original

With over 1,000 ratings on Amazon and an average of 4 stars, nostalgia is a big factor in this sauce's appeal. However, its flavor is a little too mild.

Many reviewers have noted that the oil in the sauce separates from the solids quickly upon opening, even with proper refrigeration. It’s also pricey at over $12 for 16 ounces.

Colman's

This UK brand is sold at Walmart and Amazon, where it has 4.1 stars with 586 ratings. Many love the tartar sauce, but some don’t agree with its price of $8 for 5 ounces.

The sauce has been described as addictive with a pleasantly sweet taste, which may be from its inclusion of glucose fructose syrup and sugar.

Bookbinder's

Despite mixed reviews on its sweetness and heat level, this sauce holds a 4.2-star rating on Amazon, and it’s relatively inexpensive at $5 to $6 for 9.5 ounces.

The sauce is too sweet for some, and not sweet enough for others. One stand-out component of this sauce is horseradish, which can be enjoyable for those who like a spicy bite.

Captain Toady's

This dill-infused sauce is sold on Amazon for $7 for a two-pack of 8-ounce jars. It contains ingredients like fruit concentrates, pineapple syrup, and turmeric.

Reviewers praise its thick and creamy texture. It's a great sauce for a fish fry for those who enjoy the taste of dill and want something a little different.