News

Recipes

Healthy

Baking

Cookbooks

Community

We and our partners use cookies to understand how you use our site, improve your experience and serve you personalized content and advertising. Read about how we use cookies and your choices here. By continuing to use this site, you accept these cookies.

Restaurants & Bars

New York Style thick egg roll anyone?

jason carey | Feb 14, 200804:02 PM 29
San Francisco Bay Area Americanized Chinese

Is there anywhere to find the thick skinned , 2 inch wide eggroll found in East Coast chinese places. so far All I have had out here are the skinny thin skinned ones?
I like the really junky ones filled with cabbage and ground dyed pork gristle...
looking in East Bay especially

Follow
Log In or Sign Up to comment
or

29 Comments

  1. Scott M Best bets are probably Chef Chu's http://www.chefchu.com/mall/c102/s11_new/menu.asp?dinner_time=Dinner or Panda Express...

    Best bets are probably Chef Chu's
    http://www.chefchu.com/mall/c102/s11_...

    or Panda Express

    -----
    Chef Chu's
    1067 N San Antonio Rd, Los Altos, CA 94022

    4 Replies
    1. jason carey re: Scott M I have never been to Chef Chus;; sounds good, but panda eeewww.. there is "good" bad chinese food and "bad" bad chinese , Panda...

      I have never been to Chef Chus;; sounds good, but panda eeewww.. there is "good" bad chinese food and "bad" bad chinese , Panda Express is the later.

      1. wolfe re: jason carey I don't know but maybe that was what Scott M was trying to say. "Is there anywhere to find the thick skinned , 2 inch wide eggroll...

        I don't know but maybe that was what Scott M was trying to say.

        "Is there anywhere to find the thick skinned , 2 inch wide eggroll found in East Coast chinese places. there is "good" bad chinese food and "bad" bad chinese"

      2. p
        P. Punko re: Scott M Chef Chu's does have the thick egg roll skin, but the egg rolls aren't huge (factoid, you can by the fresh egg roll/wonton skins...

        Chef Chu's does have the thick egg roll skin, but the egg rolls aren't huge (factoid, you can by the fresh egg roll/wonton skins at Safeway in the fruits and vegetable section with some other fresh noodles), and the filling is not quite the cabbage/shrimp/pork that one might be expecting. There are a number of places that also call what you would think of as a "spring roll" an egg roll. I haven't seen a restaurant anywhere, except Chu's, that has the egg roll skin the poster is looking for- and I have been looking quite hard myself.

        And I am almost certain Panda Express doesn't serve this style-

        1. a
          acgold7 re: P. Punko Panda shows both types on their website. https://www.pandaexpress.com/menu/appetizers Amazing what 10 years will do.

          Panda shows both types on their website.

          https://www.pandaexpress.com/menu/app...

          Amazing what 10 years will do.

      3. Xiao Yang You're really talking about two different things. The skinny ones are authentic Chinese and usually referred to as "Spring Rolls...

        You're really talking about two different things. The skinny ones are authentic Chinese and usually referred to as "Spring Rolls". "Egg Rolls" are American-Chinese food. I don't recall where, but I've seen both on the same menu.

        1. t
          theSauce Try Safeway Chinese deli section. Golden Dynasty in El Cerrito (now closed) used to serve east coast style egg roll where it's double...

          Try Safeway Chinese deli section. Golden Dynasty in El Cerrito (now closed) used to serve east coast style egg roll where it's double dipped in batter and fried.

          4 Replies
          1. ChowFun_derek re: theSauce Safeway also sells them in the frozen food section under their own label...they are a pale reflection of the monstrously good and...

            Safeway also sells them in the frozen food section under their own label...they are a pale reflection of the monstrously good and filling NY style egg rolls though....

            1. jason carey re: theSauce i have never in 40 years of living in the east coast seen a batter dipped egg-roll

              i have never in 40 years of living in the east coast seen a batter dipped egg-roll

              1. p
                P. Punko re: jason carey I have seen a batter dipped eggroll at Plum Garden in McHenry, IL, but never on the East Coast and never on the West Coast. The...

                I have seen a batter dipped eggroll at Plum Garden in McHenry, IL, but never on the East Coast and never on the West Coast. The egg roll was huge and the filling was MSG'd through the roof. It was a very guilty pleasure.

                1. Xiao Yang re: jason carey Maybe he was thinking of the iconic Aussie Chiko Roll.... http://www.upfromaustralia.com/chikoroll.html

                  Maybe he was thinking of the iconic Aussie Chiko Roll....

                  http://www.upfromaustralia.com/chikor...

              2. DezzerSF Have you tried the Filipino version? There's definitely a skinny Lumpia Shanghai, and a thicker Lumpia Prito.

                Have you tried the Filipino version? There's definitely a skinny Lumpia Shanghai, and a thicker Lumpia Prito.

                1. lucymom i too haven't found any east coast style egg rolls but you can get them at Trader Joe's.

                  i too haven't found any east coast style egg rolls but you can get them at Trader Joe's.

                  1. n
                    NickyPicky I have eaten the type of egg rolls you describe at JADE DRAGON in Daly City. They are an old school chinese restaurant with a bar...

                    I have eaten the type of egg rolls you describe at JADE DRAGON in Daly City. They are an old school chinese restaurant with a bar.

                    My advice: Eat in the regular dining room and order dishes off the menu. AVOID the all-you-can- eat buffet in the room off to the left when entering.

                    1. hill food ok, we all have our personal tastes. I do find it hard to believe it's difficult to locate a Gore-Tex roll. Dive. and dive without...

                      ok, we all have our personal tastes. I do find it hard to believe it's difficult to locate a Gore-Tex roll. Dive. and dive without abandon. Look for thick plexi-glass.

                      1. j
                        John1573 I'm born and raised in San Francisco's Chinatown I grow up on Chow Se Bow and Italian Salami Sandwiches from Mama's I have been...

                        I'm born and raised in San Francisco's Chinatown I grow up on Chow Se Bow and Italian Salami Sandwiches from Mama's I have been hunting for the old fashioned egg rolls that I grew up eating for like 6 months now and it's been like a UFO sighting some say they never existed and others say they do exist I know that they do exist because I have eaten them the last time I had a few of them was like 15 years ago I was in a expensive Chinese restaurant on Grant Street the egg rolls was not on the menu but I ask if they can make them and the next thing that I knew they made them for me and OMG they was the best ever I have notice that Chow Se Bow is starting to fade away (white buns) when they are in demand just like the old fashion egg roll why?

                        1. m
                          Megshead Curious if you ever found these? The comment about Chicago is priceless. Very true. Tongs in Naperville has the best.

                          Curious if you ever found these? The comment about Chicago is priceless. Very true. Tongs in Naperville has the best.

                          1. e
                            efmgdj Continuing the NY chinese guilty pleasures thread: does anyone know where to get NY style spareribs? I haven't seen them in the...

                            Continuing the NY chinese guilty pleasures thread: does anyone know where to get NY style spareribs? I haven't seen them in the bay area.

                            6 Replies
                            1. w
                              wally re: efmgdj What are NY style spareribs?

                              What are NY style spareribs?

                              1. e
                                efmgdj re: wally I mean the cheap takeout spareribs you get in NY. They are about 5 inches long, shiny on the outside (and hard for me to describe...

                                I mean the cheap takeout spareribs you get in NY. They are about 5 inches long, shiny on the outside (and hard for me to describe). Here's a picture I found that is what really fancy ones would look like; but the ones you usually get don't look that good...

                                1. Civil Bear re: efmgdj fwiw those are loin back ribs (aka babybacks). :) You can find the (relatively) cheap spareribs at Pete's BBQ in the Mission.

                                  fwiw those are loin back ribs (aka babybacks). :)

                                  You can find the (relatively) cheap spareribs at Pete's BBQ in the Mission.

                                  1. e
                                    efmgdj re: Civil Bear I'm not sure I got the right photo. The NY ones might be babybacks, but they have a "glaze" that's different than places like Pete...

                                    I'm not sure I got the right photo. The NY ones might be babybacks, but they have a "glaze" that's different than places like Pete's bbq.

                                    1. s
                                      shoulderoforion re: efmgdj they used to come in the tin foil on the inside, red chinese stuff on the outside, bags, they were dirt cheap, and they were so...

                                      they used to come in the tin foil on the inside, red chinese stuff on the outside, bags, they were dirt cheap, and they were so goddamned delicious! ~ yet another transplant who can't find good chinese here 3000 miles closer to china than brooklyn

                                  2. ChowFun_derek re: efmgdj Shiny Reddish-purple and sweet!

                                    Shiny Reddish-purple and sweet!

                              2. ChowFun_derek I had to order "SaucySusan" online, mix with a little Chinese mustard to get a nostalgic pale reflection of New York City Chinese...

                                I had to order "SaucySusan" online, mix with a little Chinese mustard to get a nostalgic pale reflection of New York City Chinese "Mommy Food"!

                                2 Replies
                                1. b
                                  Bob Copeland re: ChowFun_derek FYI - Gelson's markets in Los Angeles stock's Saucy Susan.

                                  FYI - Gelson's markets in Los Angeles stock's Saucy Susan.

                                  1. ChowFun_derek re: Bob Copeland I'm in San Fran....maybe if the state actually completes our bullet train...I'll come down for a corned beef sandwich..and head...

                                    I'm in San Fran....maybe if the state actually completes our bullet train...I'll come down for a corned beef sandwich..and head over to Gelson's with a side trip to the new Broad!!

                                2. s
                                  sfnyfam +1 here. has anyone been able to locate the flying saucer that is a NY-style egg roll (rather than the "spring roll" style ones...
                                  >

                                  +1 here. has anyone been able to locate the flying saucer that is a NY-style egg roll (rather than the "spring roll" style ones that seem to prevail here in SF?

                                  added a photo of the ideal find

                                  1 Reply
                                  1. s
                                    shoulderoforion re: sfnyfam Brother, you gotta make them yourself, a tiny infinitesimal number of Chinese restaurants even ATTEMPT these old school behemoths...
                                    >

                                    Brother, you gotta make them yourself, a tiny infinitesimal number of Chinese restaurants even ATTEMPT these old school behemoths, and then sadly, they are half as long, and like $2.50 a piece, which I would gladly pay, if they were tasty, and I haven't found those, anywhere here on the left coast.

                                    I did make this at home, this afternoon, though, and it's pretty good, If I don't say so myself. ~ yet another transplant who can't find good chinese here 3000 miles closer to china than brooklyn

                                  More From Chowhound

                                  Guides

                                  The Ultimate Spring Produce Guide: What's in Season & How to Use It

                                  by Jen Wheeler | Need a spring vegetable guide to what's in season? Consider this your spring produce cheat sheet—complete...

                                  Recipe Round-Ups

                                  Quick and Easy Instant Pot Breakfast Recipes for Less Morning Stress

                                  by Rachel Johnson | Whether the kids are still distance learning or returning to a classroom, with school back in session...

                                  Guides

                                  How to Care for Enameled Cast Iron So It Lasts a Lifetime

                                  by Kelly Magyarics | You’ve sprung for a gorgeous piece of enameled cast iron cookware; protect your investment by cleaning...

                                  Home

                                  The Best Tool to Clean a Wood Cutting Board Is Probably in Your Compost Bin

                                  by Debbie Wolfe | Home chefs love wood cutting boards because they are durable and reliable. Wood boards are attractive...

                                  Trending Discussions

                                  1
                                  Favorite Chowhound Memories
                                  Updated 6 hours ago   |   71
                                  2
                                  A Final Goodbye for Chowhound
                                  Updated 1 hour ago   |   277
                                  3
                                  Chowhound Recipes That You are Saving
                                  Updated 1 day ago   |   22
                                  4
                                  Food52: Goodbye to Chowhound, the Internet’s First Food Hub
                                  Updated 18 hours ago   |   0
                                  5
                                  NY Times: Chowhound Closes After 25 Years of Food Obsession, Wisdom and Debate
                                  Updated 3 hours ago   |   3
                                  6
                                  January–April 2022 Baking COTM: DESSERT PERSON by Claire Saffitz
                                  Updated 6 days ago   |   56