criteria : price, selection, location, knowledge
i will grade each criterion individually A-E
1. Warehouse Wines & Spirits (astor place) A-B-B-C
2. VINtage New York (broadway and 93rd) B-B-B-B
3. 67 Wine & Spirits (columbus and 67) C-A-C-B
4. NY Wine Exchange (broadway and exchange place) C-B-B-B
5. PJ Wine (broadway and 204th free same day delivery in nyc) B-A-E-A
if it wasn't for location, #5 would be at least #3. Post your comments, additions etc.