Hi everyone. SF Chowhound here. We stayed at the Aerie for our honeymoon and are thinking about making it back up to Van Island for our anniversary in Oct. I can't seem to decide between the Wickaninnish Inn or Sooke Harbour House. I know Sooke Harbour has the better reputation for food, but the setting of the Wick Inn is awfully appealing. Anyone stayed at both and have strong preferences? Thanks!