I went to Westville yesterday, the one on East 14th street, and was pleasantly surprised.
My companion and I both had hamburgers, and they were excellent. I am VERY picky about hamburgers, and only eat them at two places in all of Manhattan (Corner Bistro being one of them). Westville's burgers are right up there, grilled to perfection with a delicious Portugese Muffin standing in for the typical, and usually boring, bun.
The fries were pretty standard, the service was terrific and the "Smoky Macaroni & Cheese" was a stand-out. It was fantastic, and quite possibly the best I've ever had. YUM!
I'll be going back to Westville.