My sister and niece are visiting me in late December(from N. Carolina), and my sister wants to eat in either the Village or SoHo area. She's a pretty serious foodie and I'd like to pick something that impresses her, both food-wise and decor-wise (something open and airy, with high arches or the like).
Moderate to pricey is the range; and nothing Asian or Mexican. Most likely American (New) or Italian is the best bet.
Has anyone been to Butter on Lafayette?