Big Dog wrote about this place in Chow Alert 2 years ago. Well, I finally made it to Village Deli in Wyandanch this past Thursday and like Jim said, Phil makes some kick ass Jerk Chicken. Melt in your mouth, tender, spicy, fall off the bone Jerk Chicken. Mmmm, Ting goes so well with Jerk! Nice big portions of Jerk ($6.50) come with s tasty rice and beans side.
The owner Phil told me that he fishes all day Sunday and suggested that I come by on a summer Monday to eat some fresh grilled fish - mmmm, jerked striper!
Like Jim said, perfect 1/2 way point to the Hamptons - about 5 minutes from Exit 51 off the LIE.