+
Cookware

Is this a valid onion chopping technique?

betsy_VA | Oct 21, 201801:41 PM     35

Hi all -- Please forgive what is likely a silly question, but I watched "Julie & Julia" recently and one scene in particular has stuck in my mind: Julia Child (as played by Meryl Streep) is practicing her onion chopping technique with a mountain of diced onions. (I've appended the YouTube video link.) What struck me was *how* she was chopping: she was slamming the knife down over the onions from the top, rapidly, with what looks like a great deal of vertical force. For lack of a better term, because I am ignorant, I shall call this the whap-whap-whap technique.

To judge from the movie, this was very effective, as the knife seems to guillotine the onions. By contrast, when I chop onions, it is a measured careful slicing, drawing the knife through the onion methodically and painstakingly. I cannot imagine doing the whap-whap-whap -- wouldn't the knife lodge itself in the onion? Wouldn't one crush the onions? Is this scene realistic, in that this is how "real chefs" chop onions, or is it just a movie set where Meryl Streep is doing whatever and nobody cares?

This is causing me to question a great many things. Is this a knife skill I have not yet acquired? Is the whap-whap-whap technique reliant on a better grade of knife than I possess?

Please, onion-choppers of Chowhound, I have many questions. I welcome enlightenment.

Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Invite a friend to chime in on this discussion.

Email a Friend

More from Chowhound

The 10 Best Direct-to-Consumer Cookware Brands of 2019
Shop

The 10 Best Direct-to-Consumer Cookware Brands of 2019

by Camryn Rabideau | Welcome to Cookware Week! We're sharing our favorite cookware sets, accessories, and kitchen appliances...

8 Egregious Cookware Sins You Don't Realize You're Committing
Guides

8 Egregious Cookware Sins You Don't Realize You're Committing

by Camryn Rabideau | Welcome to Cookware Week! We're sharing our favorite cookware sets, accessories, and kitchen appliances...

11 Organization Tips from The Home Edit to Get Your Kitchen in Shape for Fall
Explainers

11 Organization Tips from The Home Edit to Get Your Kitchen in Shape for Fall

by Simone Paget | These organization tips from The Home Edit will help you get your house in shape for fall (and keep...

Essential Meal Prep Staples to Keep in Rotation
Guides

Essential Meal Prep Staples to Keep in Rotation

by Maryse Chevriere | Meal prep can seem daunting, but it’s worth a little extra effort. Here are some of the best meal...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.