News

Recipes

Healthy

Baking

Cookbooks

Community

We and our partners use cookies to understand how you use our site, improve your experience and serve you personalized content and advertising. Read about how we use cookies and your choices here. By continuing to use this site, you accept these cookies.

Coffee & Tea

Twinings Earl Grey Tea Leaves

walker | Oct 4, 202103:38 PM 22
Earl Grey Tea Blends Loose-Leaf Tea Tea

I've been buying this for years; I brew about a pot a day, steep for 4 minutes. For about a year, I've really noticed a big decline in quality. Tea is full of dust/bits, not nice tea "strings", reviews of others on Amazon have noted same. I called the company in New York, the rep argued with me but sent me a "free" can; unfortunately, it was just as bad as the others I'd been buying lately. I tried a can of Taylor's Earl Grey, cost was quite a bit more, tea looked right, but I just did not care for the flavor so went back to Twinnings. Any advice?

Follow
Log In or Sign Up to comment
or

Discussion Summary

22 Comments

  1. o
    olunia We are not tea connoisseurs by any stretch of the imagination. Yes, we experienced something similar about 20 years ago. The quality...

    We are not tea connoisseurs by any stretch of the imagination.
    Yes, we experienced something similar about 20 years ago. The quality changed with Twinnings. We found that the Earl Grey tasted a little flat the Bergamot flavour just wasn't what it once was.
    Try a specialty Tea Shop or perhaps your Health Food store might carry some loose tea. Fairmont Hotels also stock their own brand of tea.
    On a rainy day we especially enjoy Lapsang Souchong, a black tea, from Sri Lanka.
    P.S. Perhaps try steeping the Twinnings tea for 3 minutes (that may be more to your liking).
    P.P.S. I think the Fairmont tea comes in bags. The tea is large leaf so one could take it out of the bag and steep it like loose tea (at least it was large leafed when it tried it several years ago- maybe that has changed too).

    1. Nannybakes Hi walker, not a big tea drinker, but harney and sons has four or five versions of earl grey tea and they ship free. If you get...

      Hi walker, not a big tea drinker, but harney and sons has four or five versions of earl grey tea and they ship free. If you get the opportunity, you might want to take a look at their website.

      1 Reply
      1. o
        olunia re: Nannybakes I was just on their site and there is a 30 day return option. A Quality Guarantee of sorts so definitely worth a try.

        I was just on their site and there is a 30 day return option. A Quality Guarantee of sorts so definitely worth a try.

      2. m
        masha You might try the Fortnum & Mason's brand. It's available from Williams & Sonoma, https://www.williams-sonoma.com/shop...

        You might try the Fortnum & Mason's brand. It's available from Williams & Sonoma, https://www.williams-sonoma.com/shop/.... I bet it's more expensive than Twinings, but if you are looking for a quality tea ....

        (BTW Twinings is spelled with only a single, not double, "n" in the middle. See https://twiningsusa.com/?gclid=EAIaIQ.... Rhymes with mining, not sinning.)

        6 Replies
        1. o
          olunia re: masha Thank you for letting me know, as English is not my first language. Your help is very much appreciated.

          Thank you for letting me know, as English is not my first language. Your help is very much appreciated.

          1. m
            masha re: olunia You are welcome Olunia. The misspelling was in the opening post so it's no wonder that you repeated it. (It was also originally...

            You are welcome Olunia. The misspelling was in the opening post so it's no wonder that you repeated it. (It was also originally in the title but I flagged that for the mods & asked them to correct it so the thread would be picked up in future searches for "Twinings.")

            1. walker re: olunia Spelling is the hardest thing about the English language. Our verbs are so easy compared to Spanish, French, etc.

              Spelling is the hardest thing about the English language. Our verbs are so easy compared to Spanish, French, etc.

              1. walker re: walker In 5th grade on a test, the question was: What's your favorite dessert? I read the word as "desert" and the only desert I could...

                In 5th grade on a test, the question was: What's your favorite dessert? I read the word as "desert" and the only desert I could think of was "Sahara." Very offended that I got that wrong!

                1. o
                  olunia re: walker Thank you kindly for sharing. P.S. came across this CH link that could be useful to you. https://www.chowhound.com/post/buy...

                  Thank you kindly for sharing.
                  P.S. came across this CH link that could be useful to you.

                  https://www.chowhound.com/post/buy-lo...

            2. walker re: masha Thanks for the advice. Yes, this is twice as expensive.

              Thanks for the advice. Yes, this is twice as expensive.

            3. v
              valadelphia I'm a huge fan of earl grey, obsessed with bergamot. I've been drinking the Republic of Tea "Earl Greyer" for a while, I like it...

              I'm a huge fan of earl grey, obsessed with bergamot. I've been drinking the Republic of Tea "Earl Greyer" for a while, I like it quite a bit. I use the bags, but they do make a loose version:
              https://www.republicoftea.com/earl-gr...
              Smith is a quality tea purveyor (You can get a discount on first purchase), slightly more expensive:
              https://www.smithtea.com/products/lor...
              I would definitely look for a shop in your area that might sell bulk teas.

              2 Replies
              1. walker re: valadelphia There’s a market in SF, Rainbow, with a huge bulk bin area (no meat/fish is sold there.) I tried their bulk Earl Grey and didn...

                There’s a market in SF, Rainbow, with a huge bulk bin area (no meat/fish is sold there.)

                I tried their bulk Earl Grey and didn’t care for it, not sure why.

                1. m
                  Mike R. re: valadelphia A piece of TV trivia for the Earl Grey obsessed: On one episode of ABC's "Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?" (hosted by the late Regis...

                  A piece of TV trivia for the Earl Grey obsessed:
                  On one episode of ABC's "Who Wants To Be A Millionaire?" (hosted by the late Regis Philbin), Bergamot was the correct answer for (ready for this?) the $500,000 question - about the flavoring in Earl Grey tea. As I recall, the contestant had no idea and backed out...into $250,000...no mere bag o' shells. Sure, I knew it...and had a cheap chuckle accordingly.

                2. Caitlin McGrath Two possibilities that are easily accessible to the OP in San Francisco, but also available via mail order: One is Numi, a Bay...

                  Two possibilities that are easily accessible to the OP in San Francisco, but also available via mail order:

                  One is Numi, a Bay Area company that makes quality teas; I think they only sell loose-leaf tea online in bulk quantity, but their boxed teabags are readily available at local stores and use better-quality tea rather than finings (the powdery dregs in Twining's teabags).
                  https://shop.numitea.com/Aged-Earl-Gr...

                  The other is Mighty Leaf, owned by Peet's. I don’t use their Earl Grey, but their Pride of the Port blend is a personal favorite. You can buy tins of their loose-leaf tea in any Peet's shop, and you could test it out by ordering a tea if you wanted. They probably use teabags to brew it in the shops, but Mighty Leaf uses tea leaves, not finings, in fabric teabags, so quality is similar.

                  2 Replies
                  1. j
                    janeh re: Caitlin McGrath Numi Aged Earl Grey is my daily favorite - I was able to order it in tea bags on line during the stay-at-home days. They offer a...

                    Numi Aged Earl Grey is my daily favorite - I was able to order it in tea bags on line during the stay-at-home days. They offer a range of high quality and interesting teas - I often include a box with a gift of home baked treats.

                    1. Caitlin McGrath re: janeh My mother is partial to Yunnan tea, and tells me that Numi's Chinese Breakfast is a high-quality Yunnan. She had been buying the...

                      My mother is partial to Yunnan tea, and tells me that Numi's Chinese Breakfast is a high-quality Yunnan. She had been buying the teabags to take with her when traveling, and ordering loose-leaf Yunnan from other sources, until she discovered she could order a pound of Numi’s loose-leaf, and now it’s her top choice for her daily consumption.

                  2. v
                    valadelphia Coincidentally, I received a catalog in my mail last night from "Upton Tea Imports." I know nothing about them, but they offer eight...

                    Coincidentally, I received a catalog in my mail last night from "Upton Tea Imports." I know nothing about them, but they offer eight earl grey options (one is decaf). Prices for 200g range from $16-21, and they sell sample size packs.

                    2 Replies
                    1. o
                      olunia re: valadelphia I like the sample pack idea thanks for sharing.

                      I like the sample pack idea thanks for sharing.

                      1. Caitlin McGrath re: valadelphia Uptown has a reputation for high-quality teas.

                        Uptown has a reputation for high-quality teas.

                      2. c
                        chowchapnation Big tea drinkers here. We have been ordering fro Palais de The. They sell loose tea in sealed bags so you do not have to keep buying...

                        Big tea drinkers here. We have been ordering fro Palais de The. They sell loose tea in sealed bags so you do not have to keep buying the tins! The tea is excellent.
                        https://us.palaisdesthes.com/en_us/

                        1. MidwesternerTT A very-occasional tea drinker here, but I do keep Earl Grey on-hand for making cookies. (and a perhaps-monthly cuppa). Tip-toeing...

                          A very-occasional tea drinker here, but I do keep Earl Grey on-hand for making cookies.
                          (and a perhaps-monthly cuppa). Tip-toeing in to suggest Bigelow - relatively inexpensive and if you don't care for it you could always use it up in cookies.
                          https://shop.bigelowtea.com/Bigelow/b...

                          The cookie recipe from Real Simple http://food.realsimple.com/realsimple...

                          1 Reply
                          1. Caitlin McGrath re: MidwesternerTT I drink a lot of tea, but my main use for Earl Grey is in desserts — I like it more in cookies and custards than I do in a cup...

                            I drink a lot of tea, but my main use for Earl Grey is in desserts — I like it more in cookies and custards than I do in a cup.

                            By the way, I can recommend making the same style of cookies with jasmine tea (Numi has a good one) and orange zest.

                          More From Chowhound

                          Guides

                          The Ultimate Spring Produce Guide: What's in Season & How to Use It

                          by Jen Wheeler | Need a spring vegetable guide to what's in season? Consider this your spring produce cheat sheet—complete...

                          Recipe Round-Ups

                          Quick and Easy Instant Pot Breakfast Recipes for Less Morning Stress

                          by Rachel Johnson | Whether the kids are still distance learning or returning to a classroom, with school back in session...

                          Guides

                          How to Care for Enameled Cast Iron So It Lasts a Lifetime

                          by Kelly Magyarics | You’ve sprung for a gorgeous piece of enameled cast iron cookware; protect your investment by cleaning...

                          Home

                          The Best Tool to Clean a Wood Cutting Board Is Probably in Your Compost Bin

                          by Debbie Wolfe | Home chefs love wood cutting boards because they are durable and reliable. Wood boards are attractive...

                          Trending Discussions

                          1
                          Chowhound Recipes That You are Saving
                          Updated 1 hour ago   |   18
                          2
                          A Final Goodbye for Chowhound
                          Updated 1 hour ago   |   235
                          3
                          Favorite Chowhound Memories
                          Updated 1 hour ago   |   54
                          4
                          NY Times: Chowhound Closes After 25 Years of Food Obsession, Wisdom and Debate
                          Updated 10 hours ago   |   1
                          5
                          January–April 2022 Baking COTM: DESSERT PERSON by Claire Saffitz
                          Updated 3 days ago   |   56
                          6
                          What are you baking these days? February 2022 Edition
                          Updated 10 days ago   |   176