Thanks to the tip from SarahJane (who's tips are batting 100%), I swung by this little Italian store in Morrisville. I think the majority of their business is mail-order, as it looks like a shipping warehouse, but off to the side is the entrance for the retail store. They've got all kinds of goodies in there, and the Mama-owner is that sweet Italian lady who'll feed you till you burst; who you want to be adopted by. She had some cheese, sausage, capri salad, a chickpea salad and a coupla other things out to try. I bought some cheese, sausage, bresaola (!), sardines, tuna, and San Marzanos. They also have the Kinder candy variety which I love. Most of the meats are not imported, but they had some proscuitto and the bresaola that was. Apparently I had missed the buffalo mozzarella by about 3 mins.
I tried telling them to make some sandwiches so that I could come by at lunch everyday.