My wife nad I are coming to NYC for the first time in Mar to see The Producers and Hairspray. We're looking for a great spot for dinner between the matinee and the evening shows. Preferable Italian but not necessarily...looking for great food and ambiance without a huge tab. Someone's "local favorite" before a show would be great. Cara Mia, ViceVersa, and Tratoria Trecolori have all been recommended. Are these good? Any other suggestions?