A group of six college friends are getting together for a farewell dinner for one of us who is moving to Florida. I'm looking for a place where we can sit comfortably and won't be rushed out, but also a place that has a fun NY atmosphere with good food. Four members of the group keep kosher so we need lots of fish/vege options. I was thinking about Ithaka or I Coppi, but haven't been to either. Any thoughts? Would also love to hear any other ideas. We're looking to spend around $40 per person. Thanks!!