I only had the chopped BBQ chicken sandwich, but it was pretty good. Perfect fries. New place on 2nd Ave and 25th. We're ordering lunch for the office there today so I'll have more data.
The location is sorta charm-free, not downscale enough, not upscale enough.
My initial asessement is that it's not worth a long detour, but worth a stop if you're sorta in this neighborhood.