My husband and I dined there yesterday and left full and well contented. We both started with green salads (his with mushrooms, mine with blue cheese and poached pears) that were exquisite. The pears were a tad to sweet, but the greens were outstanding.
My entre of fresh pasta Bolognese was delicious and very filling. My husband thought his hangar steak and potato dish fine, but nothing special, so I was happy with my choice. The other entre, salmon, looked a bit predictable as well.
For dessert I of course chose the rich buttery chocolate cake with amazing mint ice cream with chocolate crumbs. The ice cream was my favorite item from the whole meal: it has the taste of fresh mint leaves, and you could see bits of leaves mixed in.
We left very pleased and with the feeling that we might like to come back for a special dinner sometime.
Gotham Bar and Grill
12 East 12th Street, New York, NY 10003