Explore More Cities › +
Discover the unexpected in Outer Boroughs. Explore All of New York City
Restaurants & Bars 2

Teddy's: a really pleasant little neighborhood restaurant near the BAM

cimui | Jun 1, 2008 04:49 PM

my friend and i were wandering around the neighborhood after going to the brooklyn art museum, today, and stumbled across a wonderfly pleasant neighborhood joint. it's called teddy's and it serves greek simple greek fare.

the food is not high falutin -- i.e. the tough greenleaf lettuce and GM tomato bricks that comprised the salad reflected 'value' rather than quality -- but there is also real skill in that kitchen. we ordered the sole and moussaka entrees, each of which come with salad, pita, and a choice of lemon potatoes, fries, or rice. my sole was pan fried with a lovely brown crust and came crispy despite the light lemon / butter dressing. the portion of fish was small, but given the freshness, the price ($10), and that it was perfectly cooked i have no cause to complain. the lemon potatoes i opted for -- four or five big wedges of them -- were simple, but perfectly dressed in oil and lemon juice (maybe a hit of oregeno) and very flavorful. my companion's moussaka was quite competently made. lemon in the pitcher of ice water was also a nice detail.

the service and ambiance really stood out, however. the back patio, with a garden and small fountain in the back, was a lovely place to sit and linger over dinner, while the sun gentled with the hour. service was perfect: the owners, i think, work the restaurant, and they, along with a young man in his twenties who served us our meal, were both perfectly gracious and not fake/overly friendly. (i despise false heartiness and familiarity.) they never rushed us, nor were they absentee, and cheerfully brought takeout containers for me (since i had to save room for a later meal) and my companion (whose moussaka came in a generous slab). the young man answered all of my companion's numerous questions re: the menu with knowledge and patience.

i probably wouldn't journey into brooklyn just to eat there, but i wouldn't be surprised to find myself coming out to the BAM and going to Teddy's as a side trip, more often. it's the kind of neighborhood place that makes you wish you lived in the neighborhood.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound