Restaurants & Bars

San Francisco Bay Area

Swan Oyster Depot - didn't get it


Live your best food life.

Sign up to discover your next favorite restaurant, recipe, or cookbook in the largest community of knowledgeable food enthusiasts.
Sign Up For Free
Restaurants & Bars 16

Swan Oyster Depot - didn't get it

Professor Salt | Jun 8, 2005 03:34 PM

Had a few hours to spend in SF before a flight out of Oakland, so I lunched at Swan Oyster Depot. Loved the old charm of the marble bartop and the lunch counter ambience, but I wasn't blown away by the food.

Perhaps I should have better researched what's good here. I skipped the raw oysters being it's summertime, and also because on the counter next to me was a large metal bowl of shucked oysters sitting in what looked like water (instead of oyster liquor). I don't know what the shucked oysters were for, but was afraid that's what I'd be served on the half shell.

What I ended up with: a bowl of clam chowder w/ sourdough bread, and a soft shell crab. I liked the classic white chowder well enough: obviously made in house with milk and plenty of butter. The broth tasted of mildly of clam juice and had a thin consistency I prefer to the usual starchy glop that most places serve. Smallish cubes of potatoes were cooked just unti tender, and hadn't fallen apart yet, so I could tell that batch of soup was prepared recently. Overall, a nice way to start my lunch.

I ordered a soft shell crab, which I was told was sauteed with olive oil and garlic, and came with a side of shrimp salad with Louie sauce. What came out was a crab buried under a blanket of roughly chopped, nearly raw, garlic and parsley. It must have been nearly a head and a half worth of garlic. Seriously.

If you *really* love raw garlic, by all means order this while softies are in season. However, I can't recommend this because I couldn't taste the sweet delicate crab. The shrimp salad consisted of small bay shrimp on shredded iceberg with a nice mayo & tomato sauce that somewhat resembles Thousand Island dressing.

I get the feeling that they put a great deal of time into their sauces and condiments. A small crock of mignonette sauce and freshly grated horseradish sit on the counter, and both taste wonderful.

Although I love the look and feel of the place, what I ordered just didn't merit a return trip when next time I visit SF. Nice soup, but not brilliant. Liked the very shalloty mignonette sauce, which would've been great had I ordered raw clams or oysters. But there's too many other food choices in SF to rehash what I thought was a fair to middling lunch experience. Sorry to those who just adore the place - I just didn't walk away super impressed.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound