I've seen a few posts bemoaning the general lack of tasty bagels, and I can't believe I haven't seen Sunrise Bagels mentioned here!
Run by a couple of grumpy Greeks, they offer egg sandwiches, deli stuff, soups, and a few other things--but the bagels. Oh my dear Lord, the bagels. No fancy flavors, just your poppy, your salt, your sesame. The standards. My favorite is a schmear of lox spread on sesame (I love those everything bagels, but they repeat on me all day *urp*)
It's on Ulster Avenue, across from the Jeep dealership.