+
Home Cooking

Suggestions for punching up a lobster pot pie

intentionally | Dec 20, 201601:41 PM     16

Was planning to make lobster pot pies for Christmas dinner. I initially saw this recipe on Saveur (see link), but then I thought "WWTKD?" (what would Thomas Keller do). I tracked down a version Ad Hoc did with a beautiful round of puff pastry (see photo), but can't find any recipe for it.

What I was wondering:

- Do you think buying lobster tails is sufficient, or should I buy fresh raw lobster? He has the butter poached lobster recipe, but not sure if that's overkill (also cooking raw lobster might make my kids have nightmares.)
- Related - would you incorporate a lobster stock? If so, would you also do the brandy and cream from the Saveur recipe? If so, do I need to use lobster bodies (hence fresh whole lobster) or are tail shells sufficient?
- The Saveur version just has onions - would you include carrots, pearl onions, celery, etc? (Keller cooks each individually for his chicken pot pie).
- Suggestions on how to recreate the puff pastry on top? Is it literally just using a cookie cutter, scoring and brushing with egg? (Keller has a puff pastry recipe in the Bouchon Bakery - do you think you could recreate this with frozen, or should I make it from scratch?)
- What should I serve with this, if anything? Just a salad?
- Any other suggestions?

Thanks for the help!

Lobster Pot Pie (Homard en Croûte)

Brandy adds a luxurious note to these creamy lobster pot pies.

www.saveur.com
    Image Title (Optional)
    Caption (Optional)
    Image Credit (Optional)
Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

15 Canned Sardine Hacks for a Better Snack
Test Kitchen Notes

15 Canned Sardine Hacks for a Better Snack

by Chowhound Editors | If you're unsure how to eat canned sardines, we have some intriguing ideas for you. Usually tinned...

The Shocking Truth Behind the Triscuit Name Revealed on Twitter
Food News

The Shocking Truth Behind the Triscuit Name Revealed on Twitter

by Jen Wheeler | I love learning about the genesis of odd food names (and words in general), so the recent revelation...

The Care & Feeding of Your Sourdough Starter
Guides

The Care & Feeding of Your Sourdough Starter

by Heather Reid | Sourdough is having a moment—many people are hunkering down at home and embarking on new projects...

How to Nail Your Next Virtual Happy Hour or Dinner Party 
How To

How to Nail Your Next Virtual Happy Hour or Dinner Party 

by David Watsky | Staying in is the new going out—at least for now—and we've some fun ideas for making the most of your...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.