Does anyone remember this one?
It was like an audience-participation Chopped/Iron Chef.
One audience member per side cooked with a chef; they were timed and they had "secret ingredients" or a few mandatory ingredients.
Definitely before 2004.
Possibly as old as 1994.
I've read through this list closely but the "right name" didn't seem to be there.
So maybe it was on TLC or Discovery or... somewhere else? Or the name isn't hopping out at me.