+
Home Cooking

Shepherd's Pie - With or Without Pastry

Emmalilly | Aug 21, 201611:13 PM     51

Settle an argument for me.
Growing up Shepherd's Pie was beef mince (ground hamburger for the American's) with gravy (brown gravy, just enough to hold it together and make it wonderful, not too much to make it wet) with mashed potato and cheese on top.
This is the way my grandma makes it, and how my mum makes it and so obviously how I make it.

Enter my friend who insists that Shepherd's Pie must have pastry base, then the mince mix, potato and cheese.

I argue that that is a Cottage Pie.

I know technically in the UK the difference between Shepherd's and Cottage pie comes down to the meat used (lamb for Shepherd's and beef for Cottage), however I have only ever know the above.

Does anyone have some thoughts about the true make-up of a Shepherd's Pie?

---Side Note - Do American's eat Shepherd's Pie? If not, why not??!?!?!

    Image Title (Optional)
    Caption (Optional)
    Image Credit (Optional)
Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

More from Chowhound

Husk On vs Husk Off: The Best Way to Grill Corn This Summer
How To

Husk On vs Husk Off: The Best Way to Grill Corn This Summer

by Jen Wheeler | Knowing how to grill corn on the cob is a necessary summer skill, so with Labor Day fast approaching...

9 Crazy-Good Corn Salads for Summer
Recipe Round-Ups

9 Crazy-Good Corn Salads for Summer

by Miki Kawasaki | When you've got super fresh, sweet summer corn, use it as the centerpiece of a salad, raw and straight...

Get 'Cherried' Away: 9 Creative Ways to Use Your Cherry Haul
Recipe Round-Ups

Get 'Cherried' Away: 9 Creative Ways to Use Your Cherry Haul

by David Watsky | Wondering what to do with your extra cherries? These sweet and savory cherry recipes should help...

12 Preserve Recipes That Capture Summer Fruit at Its Best
Recipe Round-Ups

12 Preserve Recipes That Capture Summer Fruit at Its Best

by Miki Kawasaki | Making summer fruit preserves is a great way to capture a taste of the season for later in the year...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.