Chowhound Presents: Table Talk with Yotam Ottolenghi and Helen Goh of Sweet: Desserts from London's Ottolenghi | Ask Your Questions Now ›

Restaurants & Bars

Manhattan Shake Shack

"Shake Shack" in Madison Sq. Park


Restaurants & Bars 11

"Shake Shack" in Madison Sq. Park

Tom Steele | Jul 4, 2004 11:03 AM

Danny Meyer has provided the city with yet another transporting experience, and topped off the restoration of Madison Square Park with a very classy retro-Deco "Shake Shack," a silvery structure at the Southeast corner, right off Madison and 23rd. My partner and I luncheoned there yesterday--I think it opened on Friday.

You might have to be from the Midwest and be of a certain age, but he's managed to capture *exactly* what comprised a "great" burger in, say, Missouri (where he's from) in 1964 or so: the Shack Burger ($3.95) is an ample patty with tomato and Romaine in a super-soft, eggy bun, served in a waxed-paper bag so you can eat it without wearing the juices on your shirt. Fresh hot krinkle fries ($1.85), "Chicago" hot dogs (untried), and all sorts of frozen custard preparations. I'm not Mr. Dessert, but my partner had a "Concretion," which was about an 18-oz. plastic cup filled with frozen vanilla custard stirred with your choice of "topping"--he got Chocolate Truffle Cookie Dough. Excellent frozen custard, quite happily reminiscent of Custard Beach's wondrous concoction. Amazingly (given NYC's blue laws), Shake Shack also offers half-bottles of wine, from $12 to $24 (for Shafer Cabernet), and draught beers (Bud Light and Brooklyn Lager). Late-night summer hours "starting soon." There are charming square tables and chairs set about the Shack, near a gorgeous new fountain.

There's nothing like this place in the city. Anyone else already in love with the Shack?

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound