General Discussion

In Search Of...

In Search of Pudding Pop Recipe


General Discussion 4

In Search of Pudding Pop Recipe

Lindsay B. | Jun 3, 2002 08:44 PM

Summer's coming and I'm looking for a homemade version of the Jello Chocolate Pudding Pops I loved as a kid. I scarcely ever see them at the grocery store these days. I wonder why?

I haven't begun to experiment with freezing pudding yet, but I'll keep you posted as to my progress. Right now, I'm brainstorming about possible pudding pop strategies, and I've got a few food science questions on my mind.

1. What kind of base do I use? I want the pudding pop texture: very smooth, free of ice crystals, and definitely puddling-like. I don't want them to be like ice cream or frozen mousse. Pudding pops stay viscous as they melt in your mouth, unlike Fudgesicles which liquify producing a mouthfeel like chocolate milk. I want to make the base from scratch, rather than using packaged Jello Pudding. Will I need to add extra gelatin or agar? Do cornstarch-based puddings freeze well?

2. Can I just pour the base into the popsicle tray, or should I freeze it part way in the ice cream freezer? I'm thinking that the second option would help prevent crystals from forming.

Want to stay up to date with this post?

Recommended From Chowhound