Just back from a whirlwind four-day trip to Puerto Rico, armed with lots of recommendations from fellow Chowhounds (and a few guidebooks). Happy to report that we didn't have a single bad meal, and we had several that were outstanding. From the best to the not-as-good:
LA CASITA BLANCA
We were tempted to try the Sunday all-you-can-eat buffet at the Hilton (right next to the Normandie Hotel where we were staying), but we decided to go for the more authentic (and lots cheaper) all-you-can-eat buffet at La Casita Blanca in the edge of the Santurce neighborhood. The area is fine during the day, but it's a bit out of the way, so you'll probably need to take a cab. The place opens at noon, and it's really charming inside. The buffet is great, over a dozen options, and all seemed like typical Puerto Rican fare that a grandmother might prepare. Great appetizer plantain chips. We had the aecerola fruit juice, which is a tasty red cherry-like fruit that's loaded with Vitamin C (had it in Brazil before). The back room has a tree growing in the middle of the dining room. The service and atmosphere couldn't be nicer. And the price was certainly right: $12.95 per person. We walked off our lunch by walking toward the El Condado section and then taking a nice long walk along the beach.
We fell in love with this place in Old San Juan on Calle San Francisco. It's a breakfast/lunch joint, and we sat at the long counter every morning to have their great coffee and mallorcas, which are puffy sweet rolls that are pressed (like a Cuban sandwich), filled with eggs, ham and cheese (or any variation) and then sprinkled with powdered sugar. Very filling and very tasty. The coffee machine is this huge Rube Goldberg-like contraption that is the size of two men. The place filled up on weekends with tourists from cruise ships, but we never had any trouble getting a seat. They have great pastries in the window, too. There's a similar place across the street, Cafeteria Mallorca, but we liked the atmosphere in La Bombanero better.
PUERTO RICO CAFE
A lovely restaurant overlooking the plaza in Old San Juan. The prices are very reasonable (especially for Old San Juan), and it was probably the best Mofongo we had (we were on a bit of a mofongo craze on this trip). If the second floor is open, there's a great view of the plaza.
Not a lot of personality (sort of like a giant Denny's) but great food, inexpensively priced. It's a short walk from the Condado section, on the edge of the Santurce neighborhood. I alerted the manager to a Chowhound report on the place, and she was thrilled. The Mofongo was superb.
We hit the Santurce Market (a giant building filled with vendors selling fruits, vegetables and meats) on Friday afternoon. We were in search of a hot sauce that a Chowhounder had written about, and we found it with no problem. It's in a booth run by a little old lady, and it's a wonderful vinegary, VERY hot, peppery sauce that she sells in old rum bottles. I'm sure she would have been astounded if I told her that I had read about her sauce on Chowhound. Unfortunately, her English was not any better than my Spanish, so I couldn't tell her about Chowhound. There's another booth around the corner from her that sells batidos (fruit shakes). Be careful if you get the large, because it's a giant shake that fills a blender carafe. We had two (you could easily split one) and then weren't as hungry for dinner as we might have been. We had read about the party atmosphere around the market on Thursday and Friday nights after everyone arrives after work. Sure enough, at around 5:00 the area filled with people standing around socializing and drinking beers while music played. It wasn't exactly a wild party scene, but it was pleasant. There are dozens of restaurants surrounding the market, and we chose Don Tello, where we had great Mofongo dishes; Bill had chicken and I had shrimp.
We had read in all the guidebooks that the fancy Dragonfly in Old San Juan was closed on Sunday evenings, but when we got into town we discovered that it was actually open. Unfortunately, we were wearing shorts, which is a no-no at Dragonfly. The folks at the door who were trying to drum up business urged us to come in anyway by telling us that we could wear sarongs and that we would be put in an out-of-the way location in the rear. Neither of those options appealed to us, so we decided to try the tapas restaurant El Picoteo in the gorgeous El Convento Hotel. The atmosphere on their plaza was probably the nicest on our trip. It was a bit pricier than the other restaurants, but the white sangria was great, as were the albondigas. The chorizo was a bit of a disappointment, not at all like Spanish cured chorizo, but more like cocktail wieners. We even tried the "diablo" ones at the suggestion of our waitress, who said they were more flavorful. I can only imagine how bland the regular chorizo must be! We split three tapas plates and sangria, which was not a lot of food, but just enough for us.
AREPAS Y MUCHO MAS
We love arepas in New York City, so we decided to give this place a try on San Francisco in Old San Juan. The prices were certainly right ($10 for two giant arepas), but they were not quite as good as some of the ones we've found in NYC. We got the ones with chicken and avacado. They certainly were filling, though.
LA FONDA EL JIBARITO
This place in Old San Juan is in all the guidebooks. It has nice, quaint atmosphere (a guitar player was there the night we went), but the food was not spectacular. Most of the dishes seem to come from steam tables at the back of the restaurant. Bill's mofongo was very good, but my tamales were a bit boring.