+

1 Place

1 Suggestion

Expand Map

1 Place

1 Suggestion

sboat | Dec 28, 201602:11 PM     4

My wife and I have been stopping at Pepe's (either eat in or take out) on our travels from PA to New England for years. We have been aware of the rivalry between Pepe's and Sally's for most of that time, but have alway's found Sally's closed when we were passing through.
Not so last night - they were open, the line at Pepe's was along the block and glacial, so we decided to try Sally's to see for ourselves.
Ushered in after a brief wait - Menus, no wine (called strike 1) - only beer. No salad (Ball 1)
Pleasant disheveled waitstaff (Ball 2) > one hour wait for pizza (swing and a miss - strike 2). Soggy, greasy pizza (no excuse for a "coal fired" pizza not to have a crisp crust) with minimal toppings (Whiffed strike 3) - $65 bill (Game over - > $5 for extra cheese - if it was extra, hate to see the standard)! One large, one small, 5 toppings total, 4 beers. We've had that at Pepe's and always felt we got our money's worth. We threw our leftovers away this morning.
I know this sounds harsh, but if this was our first New Haven pizza experience we'd never be back. Wonder if they've fallen on hard times, or have outlived their reputation.

Frank Pepe's The Spot
Want to stay up to date with this post? Sign Up Now ›

Discussion Summary

More from Chowhound

6 Places to Buy Fruit & Vegetable Plants Online
Shop

6 Places to Buy Fruit & Vegetable Plants Online

by Camryn Rabideau | If you're looking for places to buy plants online (particularly those for fruits and vegetables so...

11 Unusual Things to Grill This Summer
Shop

11 Unusual Things to Grill This Summer

by David Watsky | If you're the type who fires up the grill on most days during summer, there's a good chance that the...

Stylish & Shatterproof: Dinnerware You Don't Have to Worry About Dropping
Shop

Stylish & Shatterproof: Dinnerware You Don't Have to Worry About Dropping

by Dan Koday | Unbreakable glasses, plates, and other stylish and shatterproof dinnerware is just what you need for...

12 Stylish Coolers Way Nicer Than the Ones Your Parents Had
Shop

12 Stylish Coolers Way Nicer Than the Ones Your Parents Had

by Simone Paget | Coolers have come a long way in the last few decades. Find a stylish cooler that fits your aesthetic...

Get fresh food news delivered to your inbox

Sign up for our newsletter to receive the latest tips, tricks, recipes and more, sent twice a week.