I tried to go to Rock Creek Resort for Pie In the Sky this past July 4th weekend. I read on CH how good they are and really wanted to try them, but timing was just bad for us. It's a tiny corner of a space for maybe 6 people to eat at the counter. Small shop, resort part in the back I guess.
Sat 7/2/11 - got there after 3pm, pie long gone at 1:30pm. Sun 7/3 - hiked all day - no time to get it.
Mon 7/4/11 - Store hrs 7am-7pm, but we were leaving the area, no pie available at 8am.
Time to get Pie: 10:30am-1pm (or until they run out!!) Slices are expensive at $5.95/slice; mudpie $6.95/slice. Sold by Slice only!
Hiking part was tough. Gem Lakes is hard to find this yr, we went Sun 7/3/11 and trail is 100% snow. I liked Chickenfoot Lake better, mostly frozen but 1 mile less work to get there.