News

Recipes

Healthy

Baking

Cookbooks

Community

We and our partners use cookies to understand how you use our site, improve your experience and serve you personalized content and advertising. Read about how we use cookies and your choices here. By continuing to use this site, you accept these cookies.

Home Cooking

Help! I put too much water in my homemade split pea soup!

marymac | Jan 21, 201306:25 AM 21
Soup Peas Recipe Fixes

And now the peas are done but the soup is too thin. If I thickened it with flour and water would that ruin it? Thank You!

Follow
Log In or Sign Up to comment
or

21 Comments

  1. monavano You might try instant potato flakes or even diced potatoes. The starch will of course help to thicken and many pea soup recipes...

    You might try instant potato flakes or even diced potatoes. The starch will of course help to thicken and many pea soup recipes call for potatoes.
    Good luck!

    1. s
      Sal Vanilla re: monavano Yep. I second this. You can tamp the soup with a hand masher at the end if you do not want potato chunks. It will mash the potatoes...

      Yep. I second this. You can tamp the soup with a hand masher at the end if you do not want potato chunks. It will mash the potatoes and some peas and thicken it right up. Be sure to check the salt after the potatoes cook. They suck salt up.

      1. C. Hamster re: Sal Vanilla Potatoes definitely do not suck up salt. So don't worry about your seasoning. They do definitely thicken. I'd add them.

        Potatoes definitely do not suck up salt. So don't worry about your seasoning.

        They do definitely thicken. I'd add them.

    2. sunshine842 just turn the heat up a bit and simmer some of the water off. I like split pea soup best when some of the peas dissolve.

      just turn the heat up a bit and simmer some of the water off. I like split pea soup best when some of the peas dissolve.

      1. hotoynoodle strain the solids into a chinois, drain out the liquid and reduce that. if it's already pretty mushy, just cook it down. adding...

        strain the solids into a chinois, drain out the liquid and reduce that. if it's already pretty mushy, just cook it down.

        adding potatoes will work too.

        1. sunshine842 re: hotoynoodle Heehee -- which gives marymac the choice of A or B or c)all of the above. ;)

          Heehee -- which gives marymac the choice of A or B or c)all of the above.

          ;)

        2. p
          Puffin3 Strain off the peas. Keep the liquid. Add the amount of liquid back to the peas until you get the consistency you want. Keep the...

          Strain off the peas. Keep the liquid. Add the amount of liquid back to the peas until you get the consistency you want. Keep the rest of the 'pea water' if you want for something else. Forget the flour. You'll ruin the soup. It would taste like raw flour.
          Or if you have time/energy you could add a couple of peeled diced potatoes to thicken the soup. When they have basically disintegrated use your stick blender.

          1. i
            Indy 67 re: Puffin3 I like the suggestions to add potatoes or strain off the peas and cook down the remaining liquid, but adding flour doesn't have...

            I like the suggestions to add potatoes or strain off the peas and cook down the remaining liquid, but adding flour doesn't have to ruin the taste of the soup. If the OP uses a well-prepared roux there won't be any problem.

            In fact, if the OP cooks the roux longer before adding it to the soup, the browning would be appropriate addition to a pea soup. A fter all, a dark brown roux -- sometimes almost black -- is the backbone of gumbo.

          2. Davwud I'd just reduce it. If the peas fall apart it's no big deal. It should taste pretty much the same. DT

            I'd just reduce it. If the peas fall apart it's no big deal. It should taste pretty much the same.

            DT

            1. f
              Frank Terranova The hell made you use water. Should have made a ham stock Go get some frozen peas, like at least a pound of them, cook them according...

              The hell made you use water. Should have made a ham stock Go get some frozen peas, like at least a pound of them, cook them according to package instructions. Puree them in a processor and put through a Tammy. Ad it to your soup it will add a much more flavorful soup. Instand potato will make it grainy.

              1. m
                marymac re: Frank Terranova I use ham and ham base with the water. The taste is good, just too thin.

                I use ham and ham base with the water. The taste is good, just too thin.

              2. d
                Dave_in_PA When I make split pea soup and put the leftovers in the fridge, the next day it is much thicker. Try refrigerating overnite...

                When I make split pea soup and put the leftovers in the fridge, the next day it is much thicker.

                Try refrigerating overnite and reheat the next day.

                1. greygarious re: Dave_in_PA Agree 100%. OP, if this is the first time you've made this soup, don't thicken it. You said the taste is fine, so chill it and...

                  Agree 100%. OP, if this is the first time you've made this soup, don't thicken it. You said the taste is fine, so chill it and see what it's like when you reheat it. I'll bet the consistency then will be perfect. I learned the hard way that split pea and lentil soups need to be thin at first.

                  1. monavano re: Dave_in_PA I can spackle walls with my pea soup the next day! It really is a great point to make.

                    I can spackle walls with my pea soup the next day! It really is a great point to make.

                    1. hotoynoodle re: monavano lol, home decor, exorcist-style!

                      lol, home decor, exorcist-style!

                      1. m
                        marymac re: hotoynoodle Lots of good ideas, thanks everyone!

                        Lots of good ideas, thanks everyone!

                  2. k
                    kseiverd Don't think I've ever had homemade split pea soup where peas were not smooth and no longer resembling dried product. I'd just simmer...

                    Don't think I've ever had homemade split pea soup where peas were not smooth and no longer resembling dried product. I'd just simmer slowly and stir from time to time till where you want the soup.

                    1. chefj You can powder some more dried split Peas in a Spice Grinder or Coffee grinder and stir it into the soup it will cook in just a...

                      You can powder some more dried split Peas in a Spice Grinder or Coffee grinder and stir it into the soup it will cook in just a few minutes and should do the trick with out changing the texture(other than thickening) or flavor.

                      1. m
                        MsLiMichelle I had a similar problem when I defrosted the pea soup I made last year. I just found this thread and I used the boxed mashed potato...

                        I had a similar problem when I defrosted the pea soup I made last year. I just found this thread and I used the boxed mashed potato flakes - PERFECT solution, so thank you to the user who suggested that!

                        1. k
                          kbresach maybe a little bit of instant mashed potatoes could have worked. That works for over salted food also. But for sure the next day...

                          maybe a little bit of instant mashed potatoes could have worked. That works for over salted food also. But for sure the next day my split pea soup is always thicker. But for sure enjoy it today thin. I just happened to have made split pea soup today in my slow cooker. Here's a picture

                          1. b
                            Bongiorno I prefer to puree which will also thicken it up.

                            I prefer to puree which will also thicken it up.

                            More From Chowhound

                            Guides

                            The Ultimate Spring Produce Guide: What's in Season & How to Use It

                            by Jen Wheeler | Need a spring vegetable guide to what's in season? Consider this your spring produce cheat sheet—complete...

                            Recipe Round-Ups

                            Quick and Easy Instant Pot Breakfast Recipes for Less Morning Stress

                            by Rachel Johnson | Whether the kids are still distance learning or returning to a classroom, with school back in session...

                            Guides

                            How to Care for Enameled Cast Iron So It Lasts a Lifetime

                            by Kelly Magyarics | You’ve sprung for a gorgeous piece of enameled cast iron cookware; protect your investment by cleaning...

                            Home

                            The Best Tool to Clean a Wood Cutting Board Is Probably in Your Compost Bin

                            by Debbie Wolfe | Home chefs love wood cutting boards because they are durable and reliable. Wood boards are attractive...

                            Trending Discussions

                            1
                            Chowhound Recipes That You are Saving
                            Updated 6 minutes ago   |   14
                            2
                            A Final Goodbye for Chowhound
                            Updated 1 hour ago   |   234
                            3
                            Favorite Chowhound Memories
                            Updated 5 hours ago   |   53
                            4
                            NY Times: Chowhound Closes After 25 Years of Food Obsession, Wisdom and Debate
                            Updated 8 hours ago   |   1
                            5
                            January–April 2022 Baking COTM: DESSERT PERSON by Claire Saffitz
                            Updated 3 days ago   |   56
                            6
                            What are you baking these days? February 2022 Edition
                            Updated 10 days ago   |   176