We will be staying down in P-Town at the end of October. Are fimiliar with most resturants down there, Napi's, Fanizzi's, Lorraine's, Ross's Grill but are looking to experience one we haven't tried yet. We had a ho-hum experience at the Mews and the waiter had a bit of an attitude. I hate it when they keep pouring wine when you have only had a few sips from your glass! Too much "hurry up", I like the whole experience and to relax while eating. The food was okay - I had a rustic penne/tomato/spicy sausage combo and my husband a pork loin dish. They were okay but nothing to write home about.
We were thinking about Martin House, which looks very interesting or Chester.